Lifting the veil of secrecy on Hillsong.

Does this article come as any surprise? As the global economy plummets and millions of people, especially unbelievers, struggle to deal with the fear of death and the unknown circumstances lying ahead of them – will the knowledge that there are some who can safely ‘isolate’ themselves, while continuing to bring their false message of hope and peace, bring them any comfort?

“Who shall separate us from the love of Christ? Shall tribulation, or distress, or persecution, or famine, or nakedness, or danger, or sword? As it is written,

“For your sake we are being killed all the day long;
    we are regarded as sheep to be slaughtered.”

“No, in all these things we are more than conquerors through him who loved us. For I am sure that neither death nor life, nor angels nor rulers, nor things present nor things to come, nor powers, nor height nor depth, nor anything else in all creation, will be able to separate us from the love of God in Christ Jesus our Lord.” Romans 8:35-39


Lifting the lid on Hillsong and how the megachurch secretly makes its millions

Chloe Lyons, News Corp Australia Network, writes:

Exclusive: For the first time, News Corp lifts the veil of secrecy on megachurch Hillsong and the extent of its money-making activities which promises blessings for donations to bolster its staggering $103.4 million, tax-free revenue. A special investigation has uncovered a trove of regulations and guidelines on how the church convinces worshippers to hand over millions, through to hard-core recruitment tactics and the lengths pastors go to justify their lavish lifestyles. What started as a small Pentecostal church in suburban Sydney in the 1980s is now an international brand with 37 churches in Australia and another 91 spread across 28 countries boasting celebrities such as Justin Bieber and his wife Hayley, Nick Jonas and Selena Gomez.

In 2018, Hillsong raked in $103.4 million in revenue in 2018 and of this, an eye-watering $79.6 million was donated.

Hillsong spent most of its total revenue on church services ($50 million) which includes staff remuneration and campus operating costs, followed by venue operating costs ($12.4 million), global and local benevolent activities ($11.3 million) and arts, media and conferences ($10.3 million)

New York head pastor Carl Lentz pictured with Justin Bieber and Lil Wayne on Instagram.
New York head pastor Carl Lentz pictured with Justin Bieber and Lil Wayne on Instagram.

A brochure aimed at encouraging people to donate to the Hillsong Foundation tells followers those who donate big have the honour of being able to “resource God’s House”. The hierarchical donation structure takes worshippers from being a faithful believer to closer to God as a top-tier “Kingdom Builder” for a cool $5000. Followers encouraged to tip money into Hillsong coffers are offered three different statuses and an opportunity to earn more blessings based on how much money they donate.

* For a donation of $5000 or more, followers can earn the label of Kingdom Builder,

* Donations between $2500 and $4999 earn the title of Vision Impactor;

* And for up to $2499 they can be part of the Army of Faithful Believers.

Around the globe, 150,000 followers pack into Hillsong’s churches and theatres every week where they religiously part with their cash in the hopes of being favoured by God. Last year was the church’s most successful year for donations in Australia, which has dramatically increased since 2014 ($54.7 million), 2015 ($63.1 million), 2016 ($73.3 million) and 2017 ($76.7 million). Internal Hillsong documents obtained by News Corp reveal how the church uses faith to drum up financial support.

Followers are urged to donate above the standard 10 per cent of their income with the promise of getting the Lord’s blessing.

NED-1373-Hillsong Donation Ranks - 0
 

Leaders of Hillsong’s Connect Groups – which are small church groups that meet outside of services – are told to set a financial ‘Faith Goal’ and “build faith around giving generously and expecting to see God move miraculously”.

“Make it clear that this is a faith commitment so it’s good to encourage people to stretch where possible,” the document advises, before the caveat: “At the same time, encourage people to be realistic”.

“Abundant generosity not only leads to blessing in our own lives but to the lives of people around the globe,” a second document reads.

And a third boldly declares donating will “spark UNUSUAL miracles!”

Money from these groups and the Hillsong Foundation is funnelled into church expansion, global missions and a number of Hillsong brands including Hillsong Channel, the church’s television station. Among the testimonies of those who gave big to the foundation was a couple who said their donation prevented them from being laid off work.

Bobbie Houston, who is the co-founder, and Global Senior pastor of Hillsong Church & President of Hillsong Music, Hillsong Channel & Hillsong College. Picture: Supplied
Bobbie Houston, who is the co-founder, and Global Senior pastor of Hillsong Church & President of Hillsong Music, Hillsong Channel & Hillsong College. Picture: Supplied

“It’s amazing what happens when you take a step of faith in generosity,” they gushed.

The Foundation’s 2016 – 2017 brochure placed a heavy focus on outreach work funded by the donations, but Hillsong’s 2017 annual report shows most of the money went back to the church. More than $18.4 million was raised by the foundation in 2017, but just $2.95 million went towards benevolent activities. The majority of the money went to Hillsong’s Australian building facilities ($8.8 million), followed by its media and arts arm ($4.2 million) and missions and church planting ($1.65 million). The foundation raised $17.5 million in 2018, but that year’s report does not include a breakdown of where the money was spent.

Tanya Levin, 48, released her Hillsong expose, People in Glass Houses: An Insider’s Story of a Life in and out of Hillsong in 2007 after spending her formative teenage years at the church. The outspoken Hillsong critic told News Corp when she first attended, the church was “small, nice, warm” and family oriented, but eventually its focused locked onto donations and generating revenue.

Hillsong on generosity:

When meeting weekly and bi‐weekly within our small groups we have encouraged our leaders to build faith around giving generously and expecting to see God move miraculously. 

Make it clear that this is a faith commitment so it’s good to encourage people to stretch where possible.

Take the time during your next meeting to inspire your group to set a (financial) Faith Goal for 2015, and let’s believe together for our Nation Builders to spark UNUSUAL miracles! 

Questions to help people grow as leaders: Describe how you came to a revelation of tithing and honouring God with your finances.

The vision of Kingdom Builders was birthed out of a prayer from Pastor Brian – a prayer for a strategy to raise finance for our building programs.       

Plan for generosity. Every significant sacrifice requires a plan. Never underestimate the power of budgeting for your generosity!

Abundant generosity not only leads to blessing in our own lives but to the lives of people around the globe.

Quotes sourced from Hillsong’s internal documents and guidelines

Ms Levin said although she had left the church, stories she was told by current members showed “pretty much nothing’s changed”.

“We can’t all be millionaires, the formula doesn’t work. Not everyone who gives is going to get,” she said of Hillsong’s controversial donation tactics.

“(There’s) a lot of people who have lost a lot of money through this. Marriages break down. That’s the kind of thing that happens when you do this to people, tell them they’ve got to give money to be all right – to be faithful.”

The enduring appeal of Hillsong could be put down to modern’s society’s “epidemic of loneliness”, Ms Levin said.

“It’s very much about community,” she said.

Inside the Hillsong Conference.
Inside the Hillsong Conference.

“People really want to be a part of something bigger than themselves.”

Increasing congregation numbers is vital for Hillsong to keep the donations flowing and a team of dedicated volunteers are on hand to encourage potential new followers. An internal guideline for Hillsong’s follow-up team, complete with a script, urges the volunteers to repeatedly call and text those who leave their contact information when signing in to a church service for the first time.

New contacts are allocated to volunteers each Monday in an online platform where notes about previous calls, emails and face-to-face interactions are recorded. The goal is to have four “successful” connections with each person over a 12-week time period and eventually funnel them into Connect Groups – where extra donations are encouraged – volunteering roles, baptisms and Hillsong’s bible college. It is not just collection plates bolstering Hillsong’s coffers.

NED-1366-Text-Guide - 0
The top five streamed songs of Hillsong’s three bands, the creatively named Hillsong UNITED, Hillsong Young & Free and Hillsong Worship, have netted almost half a billion listens on Spotify.

Hillsong UNITED is also in the app’s top 10 list of Australian artists streamed overseas. Huge crowds flock to see the trendy band perform and its young, energetic members look more suited to rock music than the contemporary Christian genre. Its 2019 US tour had US$250 VIP tickets on offer which included a meet and greet with the band, a gift bag and on-site host.

In 2017, Hillsong made more than $14.2 million from ‘Music and Resources’, but this metric was absent from its 2018 financial report.

Hillsong Untied are part of the megachurch’s big business.
Hillsong Untied are part of the megachurch’s big business.

Yearly conferences are big events for Hillsong with highly curated marketing and music festival vibes making them a highlight for followers. Many of them look more like rock concerts than religious events with photos showing thousands of people packed into stadiums in front of hi-tech stages. Almost 51,000 people attended Hillsong’s various conferences in 2018, according to its annual report, contributing more than $7.2 million to its income.

This strong focus on donations to raise revenue is unique to modern churches, according to Professor of sociology and social research at Deakin University, Andrew Singleton.

NED-1366-Phone-Script - 0
Older churches, such as the Catholic Church, rely on investments, property ownership and sales, and bequests – whereas megachurches have to leverage larger congregation numbers to drum up direct donations. Prof Singleton said while “historically, all churches have relied on voluntary contributions to get by”, Pentecostal churches operated as single entities and “required financial independence to survive”. This has manifested itself as a strong focus on donating to the church and “ceremony” around giving during services, according to Prof Singleton.
Hillsong’s stars from Young & Free.
Hillsong’s stars from Young & Free.

“The most important thing to realise is how the churches cultivate a culture of giving,” he said.

“That’s the big difference between what you see in the main line Catholic and Anglican churches”.

As of 2018, Hillsong had $19 million in plant, property and equipment assets, which included two buildings in Newcastle West purchased for a combined $4 million for its Newcastle campus. The boom of Pentecostalism is in stark contrast to Australian society in general which is growing increasingly secular.

Houses of God – Check out the million-dollar homes of pastors from Australia’s megachurches:
 
$1.5 Million – John and Danielle Pearce
 
Senior Ministers of C3 Church Kawana Waters and the Regional Directors for C3 Church Australia
• Home in Alexandra Headland, Queensland, purchased in March 2015 for $1.5 million
• Four bedrooms, three bathrooms, two car spaces on 880m2
• Three-level, award-winning, architecturally-designed home with coastal views and a pool
 
 
$3.4 Million – Phil and Chris Pringle
 
Founders of megachurch C3
• Home in Mona Vale, NSW, purchased in September 2012 for $3.4 million
• Four bedrooms, two bathrooms, one car space on 645m2
• The lavish cliff-top home features an infinity pool overlooking the ocean and a chic white colour palette
 
 
$1.9 Million – David and Kirrily Smeallie
 
Head pastors at C3 Mosman
• Home in Frenchs Forest, NSW, purchased in August 2019 for $1.9 million
• Five bedrooms, three bathrooms, three car spaces on 947m2
• Sprawling two-storey home with pool and a marble bathrooom
The couple previously owned a four bedroom, two bathroom home in Mosman, Sydney, which they bought in 2015 for $1.5 million and sold for $2.8 million in 2019. After extensive renovations by the Smeallies, that home is now described as “flawless in every aspect” with a “no cost spared array of high-end features”.
 
 
$1.37 Million – Peter and Laura Toganivalu
 
Global pastors of Hillsong Young & Free. Laura is the daughter of Hillsong leaders Brian and Bobbie Houston
• Home in Glenhaven, NSW, purchased in April 2019 for $1.37 million (co-owned with a Houston)
• Five bedrooms, two bathrooms, six car spaces on 904m2
• Home features vaulted ceilings, a spa bath en-suite and an in-ground pool and spa
 
 
$1.67 Million – Jerry and Jo Groenestyn
 
Head pastors at the Northern Beaches Hillsong Campus
• Home in Cromer, NSW, purchased in November 2017 for $1.67 million
• Four bedrooms, two bathrooms, one car space on 569m2
• An extensive outdoor area features a fire pit and spa with views towards the ocean
 
 
Land $1.4 Million, House $800,000 – Joel and Julia A’Bell
 
Joel was previously a Hillsong pastor and now runs his own church, Revitalise, in Sutherland Shire
• Land purchased at Greenhills Beach, NSW, for $1.4 million in 2019
• A development application for the $800k home features a pool, theatre room and four bedrooms with walk-in robes
• The plan also provides for a secondary dwelling
 
 
$3.85 Million – Darlene and Mark Zschech
 
Darlene left Hillsong in 2011, but wrote some of their biggest musical hits. She and Mark are now head pastors at megachurch HopeUC
• Home in Terrigal, NSW, purchased for $3.85 million in May 2017
• Four bedrooms, five bathrooms and two car spaces on 1258m2
• The three-level, clifftop home features panoramic ocean views and marble flooring
 
The number of people who identify as having ‘no religion’ increased from roughly 4.69 million to 6.94 million – or 48 per cent – from 2011 to 2016, according to the latest Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) census data. Curiously, adherents to ‘Christianity’ decreased by 7 per cent during the same time period, but within that category members of the Pentecostal church increased from 238,000 to 260,500. Hillsong experienced a 27 per cent growth in average weekly church attendance between 2014 and 2018, according to its annual reports, jumping from 34,083 people to 43,239 at its Australian and Bali locations.

The majority of its flock are aged between 20 and 34 (37.4 per cent), followed by 35 to 49 year olds (20.3 per cent) and 10 to 19 year olds (19.1 per cent), according to its 2017 report. The increase in Pentecostalism could be put down to the “mass media appeal” of Hillsong and other megachurches, according to University of Queensland professor of the history of religious thought, Philip Almond.

MORE NEWS

Aussie Hillsong pastors and their lavish lives of luxury

Hillsong’s secret guide, text and phone scripts

‘God uses our finances’: How Hillsong makes its money

Brian Houston outside the White House. He is the Global Senior pastor of Hillsong Church & President of Hillsong Music, Hillsong Channel & Hillsong College. Picture: Supplied
Brian Houston outside the White House. He is the Global Senior pastor of Hillsong Church & President of Hillsong Music, Hillsong Channel & Hillsong College. Picture: Supplied

“If you’re a young person and you decide to investigate religion and you go down to the local Anglican Church on a Sunday morning and there’s 10 people and a lady over 50 playing an electric organ, and then you go to Hillsong.

“Hey, I know where you’re going to end up.

“This is old vs young, it’s big vs small, and it’s vibrant vs dull.

“It’s marketed itself really well to a certain demographic.”

Another point of appeal, according to Prof Almond, is modern megachurch’s “jelly” theology which “doesn’t make any great demands of people”.

“This isn’t fire and brimstone, this isn’t about sin and guilt. This is about making people feel good.

“It’s a feel good, commercialised, a kind of consumer religion.

“If the theology were any softer, it would disappear completely.”

Originally published as Lifting the veil of secrecy on Hillsong



Categories: Uncategorized

%d bloggers like this: